Ways to Help Second Language Writers Experience a Sense
of Ownership of their Writing
Before I enumerate the different ways teachers might follow in order to help second language writers experience a sense of ownership of their writing, I would like to say that the teacher alone cannot succeed; there are a lot of other factors that play a great role in the teacher/student’s success, such as the instructional materials selected; they should meet the teaching objectives of particular groups of student-writers without neglecting their level and the skills they need to develop. (Let’s not forget that there are some available supplementary materials in the form of teaching guides, transparencies, test packets, and computer software programs intended for ESL instruction and that could prove to be very helpful to assist teachers in their jobs.)
How can second language writers be given opportunities to self-sponsor their writing ? How should teachers proceed to create classrooms for authors and have students own their writing?
A- Eclectic Approach :
There are several approaches to teaching writing as creative communication ( the Controlled-to-Free Approach, the Free Writing Approach, The Communicative Approach, The Process Approach……. ). For ESL classes , Raimes ( 1983 ) recommends the use of an eclectic approach that is responsive to learners’ needs as their skills develop, and asserts that there is no one answer to the question of how writing should be taught. Oluwadiya (1990) advocates a "marriage" of the techniques of the product-oriented approach with the techniques of the process-oriented approach; we should aim at using an enriched process approach that borrows freely strategies and techniques that belong to the product-oriented approach.
B- Skill-Getting & Skill-Using :
In order to make students effective writers who own their writing, we should train them in Composing, exploring, conceptualizing, drafting, revising, creating… not only writing or transcribing. One of the most difficult and important tasks for the teacher is to know how to effectively bridge the gap between skill-getting ( writing down , writing in the language è Form) and skill using (flexibility measures, expressive writingè function ) activities , which means teaching "at the bone level, not only at the skin." One possible solution would be to minimize the use of writing practice activities that are manipulative or impersonal in nature and choose instead activities that are contextualized, meaningful, and personalized, even when students are focusing primarily on form . Moreover, it is suggested to use a blend of diverse tasks that elicit performance ranging from the careful style to the vernacular style. As students’ competence increases, writing assignments should become less structured, less teacher-directed, and more creative in nature. After all, students should be encouraged to use the language independently to inform, narrate, describe, question, persuade, express feelings and attitudes, discuss ideas, and support points of view .
C- Composing Process & Phases of Instruction :
When designing writing practice at the Advanced level, it is important to include various aspects of the composing process in the instructional sequence. The various steps of the composing process need to be taught, and practiced More Overtly than has typically been the case in many foreign language programs. Therefore, a few texts have been developed for advanced students (Vald¾ s, Dvorak, and Hannum, 1984; 1989) that lead them through various steps or stages as they engage in creative and expressive writing, concentrating on organization, style, and the development of greater precision in grammar and vocabulary in the process. In these texts students practice various types of writing, including description, narration, and exposition, using rhetorical techniques such as definition, classification, comparison and contrast, and argumentation.
The typical writing lesson involves three phases :
1) Prewriting: (It
is defined by Oluwadiya as "any structural activities – oral,
written or experiential -- that influence active student participation
in thinking, talking, writing, and working on the topic under focus
in a writing lesson, stimulating higher-level thinking as well as
"Pre-writing activities generate ideas; they encourage a free flow of thoughts and help students to discover both what they want to say and how to say it on paper. In other words, pre-writing activities facilitate the planning for both the product and the process."
Pre-writing activities should be used as a therapy to help inexperienced or incompetent students who tend to slow down their pace of writing by insisting on a perfect essay from the onset. These students should be made aware that by doing so, when they try to put down only the "right word in the right sentence." they hinder their own fluency and give themselves the "Writer’s Block." They should be told to leave matters of correctness and form to the revision and editing stages, when they can re-see, rethink, and rewrite their essay to polish it as well as make it Reader Centered – not Writer Centered – prose.
2) Composing (focuses on organizational and mechanical considerations)
The teacher's attitude toward correction, the way in which he offers it to students, and students’ own feelings about the teacher in general are significant factors in the effectiveness of correction strategies.
It is recommended that teachers focus more on process in their comments and use multi-draft assignments; they should teach students how to use feedback to enhance their writing skills ( Self-correction has proven to be very effective; being aware of one’s errors and rewriting them using problem-solving techniques is significantly beneficial for developing writing skills.)
Moreover, teachers should provide feedback that addresses the specific instructional needs and expectations of the various groups of student-writers. While certain student-writers expect feedback on the content, style, and rhetoric, others may value corrective feedback of their lexical and grammatical misuses. Consequently, ESL classroom practices need to enrich the lexical and grammatical resources of student-writers as well as equip them with the strategic, discourse, and cultural knowledge in order to help them improve their fluency, manage the complexity of their composing, and engage their readers.
E- Extensive Reading :
A high degree of writing competence can be achieved through
extensive reading (Krashen) . Teachers should encourage their students
to read a lot by giving them the opportunity to make oral/written presentations,
Back to Nada's Online Materials!